Thread

#Morris 八十年经验的”老中医“也无法回答的50个问题: 1.中医的核心理论中,哪些概念是可被测量的? 2.“气”是否有明确的物理定义、单位和检测方法? 3.经络是否能被任何独立实验室稳定检测到? 4.阴阳五行是自然规律,还是哲学隐喻? 5.中医理论是否允许被证伪?在什么情况下算“错”? 6.中医是否提出过明确、可检验的预测? 7.同一病人,不同中医给出不同诊断,哪一个是对的? 8.如果结论依赖“悟性”,它还能算知识吗? 9.中医是否有一套统一、标准化的理论公理体系? 10.若一个理论无法形式化表达,它如何进入科学讨论? 11.哪些中药或方剂通过了三期随机双盲对照试验? 12.若没有对照组,如何区分治疗效果与自然恢复? 13.中医治疗的失败率和不良反应率是多少? 14.有多少中医研究符合 CONSORT 或 GCP 标准? 15.安慰剂效应在中医疗效中占比多少? 16.中医是否系统性公布过“无效结果”? 17.如果疗效真实,为何难以在国际顶级医学期刊复现? 18.为什么疗效高度依赖“名医”,而非方法本身? 19.同一方剂,不同批次药材,疗效如何一致? 20.如果疗效无法稳定复现,凭什么推广给公众? 21.感冒等自限性疾病,如何证明不是“自己好”的? 22.若不治疗也会好,治疗的意义如何界定? 23.中医治好的病例中,有多少有未治疗对照? 24.慢性病的波动期,如何区分“回归均值效应”? 25.病情好转是否被系统量化,而非主观描述? 26.心理安慰与情绪改善是否被排除? 27.若病情恶化,是否也计入统计? 28.中医是否有明确的“无效判断标准”? 29.复发率是否长期追踪? 30.若治疗延误导致恶化,责任如何界定? 31.同一疾病,不同中医为何诊断完全不同? 32.如果诊断不一致,治疗依据是什么? 33.古籍理论互相矛盾时,如何取舍? 34.不同流派结论冲突时,谁来裁决? 35.理论更新是否基于实验,还是权威? 36.新发现若否定经典,是否被允许? 37.若理论正确,为何现代解剖学无法对应? 38.脏腑功能为何与实际器官功能不一致? 39.若理论可调整解释一切,是否已失去解释力? 40.内部无法自洽的体系,如何对外声称可靠? 41.中医是否系统性淘汰过无效疗法? 42.若无效,是否公开承认并停止使用? 43.误诊或延误治疗的真实统计数据在哪里? 44.对儿童、癌症患者使用未经验证疗法是否合伦理? 45.若有效,为什么现代医学不能直接吸收? 46.若不能被吸收,是否说明其缺乏可验证性? 47.为什么疗效常随宣传强度变化? 48.是否存在幸存者偏差? 49.若仅作为文化或安慰疗法,是否应明确标注? 50.如果你生死攸关,你愿意只靠中医吗?

Replies (37)

Do you have any concrete examples of what type of tech you have in mind that shares human values?
🛡️
This is crushing all of the parsers, except those that are purely Asciidoc. 😂 Need to work on them, some more. Just look at the raw Asciidoc source.
🛡️
This is the #bookstr macro I want to use for publishing all of the Great Works, so anyone interested should scream at me, now. (Or don't, and scream at me, later, as I am always around. 😂) I've been working on it, for months, by attempting to publish different `30040` structures and see how I would best-address the individual parts. Also, I've been reading a lot of citation pattern documentation. That's how I came to the conclusion to make one generic book macro, rather than something #Bible specific. #christian #catholic #biblestr
🛡️
The #bookstr 📖 macro is hierarchical. If you find a section or verse event, in the wild, you can just drop the section tags, to find the whole chapter, or the section and chapter tags, to find the whole book. This means you can always backtrack to the entire publication, from just one quoted line or paragraph. We are going to be having these tags in all of our publications, so you will be able to "Bible-search" and "Bible-cite" any of our books! I love books. Name checks out. 😎
🛡️
Some things: 1. *You have to scroll-right on mobile.* Unlike Jumble and Alexandria, Wikistr is an unapologetic desktop-focused app, and that's why it's cool. If you have a wide screen, you can open up lots of panels, and make some wider, and it turns into the document version of a Bloomberg terminal. Credit for this design goes to @fiatjaf. 2. The different Wikistr themes have different looks, help text, and *different relays*, for the document search and the social interactions. #Quranstr uses Nostrabia, for instance, whilst #Biblestr focuses on Christpill. The basic #Wikistr has been left secular. I am looking for a Jewish relay, but haven't yet found one, so #Torahstr uses generic ones. 3. All have light and *dark themes*. The light themes are so much prettier, but I know you will all use the dark ones. 4. All themes take *your personal relay list* into account, and share a few document relays, so you can just pick the theme you like and use that. 5. *We printed the Bible first because Gutenberg did* and he's the inspiration for our Nostr printing press. We will proceed to print all other open-license books we can find, including the Torah, Quran, classical authors, English literature, etc. They will all be searchable, with this mechanism. 6. This wikistr *can find and render kinds 300023, 30041, 30817, 30818, 30040*, and the comments are kind 1111 and you can vote at the top of the panels, using the up/down arrow buttons. Only kinds 30817/818 are in the left-most panel feed, to keep it uncluttered and true to the origins. The hyperlinks mentioned are: The original Wikistr, that I forked: https://wikistr.com/ Wikistr Imwald 🌲 https://wikistr.imwald.eu/ https://torahstr.imwald.eu/ https://quranstr.imwald.eu/ https://biblestr.imwald.eu/ GM
🛡️
These never really took off because we have kind 30023. Nobody cares, if a microblog has a typo.
🛡️
It's worth noting that Psalm 42 is prayed by the priest and altar servers at the beginning of every Catholic Mass celebrated according to the old form (1962 and previous).
🛡️
Is it maybe in Psalm 123 or 125. The Douay has an off-by-one thing going on with some of the Psalm numbers. That translation combines two of the early psalms that are separated in other translations.
🛡️
Is this on a public repo yet? I'd love to take a peek at the code.
🛡️
This is actually an expanded version of a previous post. There's still plenty of room for more expansion. Can add a bit, every year.
A reading from the Book of the Prophet Isaiah Thus says the LORD: Here is my servant whom I uphold, my chosen one with whom I am pleased, upon whom I have put my spirit; he shall bring forth justice to the nations, not crying out, not shouting, not making his voice heard in the street. A bruised reed he shall not break, and a smoldering wick he shall not quench, until he establishes justice on the earth; the coastlands will wait for his teaching. I, the LORD, have called you for the victory of justice, I have grasped you by the hand; I formed you, and set you as a covenant of the people, a light for the nations, to open the eyes of the blind, to bring out prisoners from confinement, and from the dungeon, those who live in darkness. The word of the Lord. #light #christ #savior #emmanuel image
In the west it is always 50/50, that's the whole point in the principles behind divide'n conquer. Split the population in two half's that see each other as mortal enemies. Just remember, people basically have the same hopes and dreams for a future of liberty, prosperity, safety and work. They have just been deliberately feed different stories of how to achieve that and who is to blame. This is no coincidence. In a family or any group that is not manipulated by two separate stories, the best argument tends to win over time or a consensus is established (no matter how stupid it is).
🛡️
Monero is 2 spots away from becoming a household name like Bitcoin, Ethereum, Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin, Solana, Doge, Tether, and XRP. There will be just as many vendors if not more that will accept monero as Bitcoin. I'm not saying Monero is a Bitcoin killer but what I am saying is that Bitcoin will need to innovate if it wants to maintain the number 1 spot. image
I'd pay for the following: 1. #prepper How To. Other than having a solar power battery, a small generator, some flashlights and sleeping bags and wool blankets, I'm not sure where to begin. 2. #gun #gunstr How To: - First self defense/home defense firearm - what do get and where to keep it. - What course to take and how many hours of education/certification are needed. - If I'm gone, teaching her to use it. Do I get a different gun for her? Other than shooting a .22 when I was a kid I have no experience. You could post articles and get zapped for this, but as someone who sells digital education "on the outside" if it were me I'd: - Code a simple Wordpress website that connect to BTC pay server - Have someone like me pay via lightening and then have access to the course.. - We read at 250 words per minute and I'd be happy to read articles that take 16-20 min each, so 4k-5k words. I'd read as much as you wanted to share. This is a great way to get non-KYC sats. You could charge the sats equivalent of $95 for sure and maybe $150. For each one. For me that's a no brainer coming from someone here. I don't have to figure out who to listen to on YT, I just trust a bitcoiner. Just a thought. I've been thinking about how I can do the same with a course as it's a great way to provide value and get those non-KYC sats. #asknost #gunstr #gun #prepper #nonkyc #bitcoin #v4v #circulareconomy