**Claim for Discussion** **AI Verdict Analysis** An AI analyzed the following claim. Is the verdict correct? --- **ORIGINAL CLAIM:** > "Remdesivir causes kidney failure and was responsible for killing COVID patients in hospitals, and this is why many people died after receiving it" — **Mel Gibson** at 44:09 Topic: COVID-19 treatment harm --- **VERDICT: FALSE** *Remdesivir doesn't cause kidney failure; COVID-19 itself damages kidneys* **Confidence: 92%** 📊 18 sources analyzed | 12 peer-reviewed | 3 debate rounds | 20 rebuttals --- **WHY IT FAILS:** • Kidney function IMPROVED in remdesivir patients (creatinine decreased, not increased) • MORE untreated patients needed dialysis (11.1%) vs remdesivir (6.7%) • COVID-19 itself causes AKI in 10-20% through direct viral invasion **WHAT'S TRUE:** • Pharmacovigilance databases do show statistical associations warranting monitoring • SBE-β-CD excipient raised theoretical nephrotoxicity concerns initially • Kidney function monitoring is appropriate for critically ill COVID patients on any medication --- **THE DECISIVE EVIDENCE:** **1. DIALYSIS RATES INVERTED** Nature study showed 11.1% of control patients required dialysis versus only 6.7% of remdesivir patients. If remdesivir caused kidney failure, this pattern would be reversed. This directly contradicts the causation claim. 📎 Nature - Impact of remdesivir on renal functions [PEER-REVIEWED] **2. KIDNEY FUNCTION IMPROVED** Controlled trial of 339 patients showed plasma creatinine decreased by -6 μmol/l with remdesivir and -57 μmol/l in those with renal insufficiency. Kidney function improving during treatment is incompatible with nephrotoxicity. 📎 Nature - Remdesivir impact study [CLINICAL-TRIAL] **3. COVID CAUSES AKI INDEPENDENTLY** COVID-19 causes AKI in 10-20% of hospitalized patients through direct viral kidney invasion, cytokine storm, and multi-organ failure. The Frontiers study concluded remdesivir has 'little or no effect on AKI risk.' 📎 Frontiers - COVID-19 and Acute Kidney Injury [META-ANALYSIS] --- **OPPOSE WINS DECISIVE** --- From: *Joe Rogan Experience #2254 - Mel Gibson* [Watch on YouTube]() --- **Is this AI verdict correct? Debate below.** Source: AI Analysis of PowerfulJRE - Joe Rogan Experience #2254 - Mel Gibson What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** AI Verdict on claim by Joe Rogan: "The CIA used cocaine trafficking to fund operations, similar to the Iran-Contra affair, with Freeway Ricky Ross unknowingly selling CIA cocaine in Los Angeles" The AI concluded: MOSTLY FALSE - CIA tolerated Contra-linked trafficking but didn't operationally direct Ross cocaine sales. Winner: oppose (margin: clear) Source: AI Analysis of PowerfulJRE - Joe Rogan Experience #2419 - John Lisle What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** There are 47 biological males housed in women's prisons in California alone Original quote: "California has 47 biological males that are housed in women's prisons. At least." Source: Joe Rogan at 1:10:23 on PowerfulJRE - Joe Rogan Experience #2418 - Chris Williamson What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** Oscar Wilde was jailed and died in exile as a peasant in France in the 1800s because he was gay, showing UK's history of persecuting people for 'improper behavior' Source: Chris Williamson at 45:40 on PowerfulJRE - Joe Rogan Experience #2418 - Chris Williamson What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** OpenAI is the short in the AI space and is overvalued, facing challenges from Google, Anthropic, and Grok who are beating them consistently in leaderboards Source: Jason Calacanis at 39:25 on All-In Podcast - Epstein Files Fallout, Nvidia Risks, Burry's Bad Bet, Google's Breakthrough, Tether's Boom What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** Denmark does not recommend universal hepatitis B birth dose despite having similar hepatitis B prevalence to the United States Original quote: "when we have a similar pre prevalence of hepatitis B in the United States and as they do in Denmark why Denmark has decided that they should not routinely recommend it to children um and that they should identify uh children who may be higher risk" Source: Dr. Hogue at 1:07:15 on Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) - Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) - December 5, 2025 - Day 2 of 2 What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** In seasonally breeding animals, high levels of melatonin shrink ovaries and make animals infertile, and shrink male testes from grape-size to rice-grain size Original quote: "Melatonin in males of seasonal breeders takes the testes and shrinks them... these little Siberian hamsters... have testes about the size of, sort of typical table grapes... When days get shorter and the melatonin signal gets longer... Those same hamsters would have testes that would involute to the..." Source: Andrew Huberman at 47:41 on Andrew Huberman - How to Defeat Jet Lag, Shift Work & Sleeplessness What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** What’s the best subreddit for meeting new people? Source: r/AskReddit (u/Girthiousthe1st) What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** What’s a company you refuse to use even though everyone else seems fine with it? Source: r/AskReddit (u/Psychological_Sky_58) What do you think?

**Claim for Discussion** What do think about Larry Stylinson? Source: r/AskReddit (u/Ok-Feeling-2038) What do you think?